When Nathan Dickey opened the door on his Cleveland, Tennessee, storage unit Nov. 11, 2020, nearly all of his belongings, more than $28,000 in work tools, had vanished.
Only two items were left inside: a table and a Crock-Pot.
Several weeks later, when Dickey and his wife, Devan Dickey, returned to Posey Storage Solutions, they discovered that nearly everything in a second unit they rented had been stolen as well.
This time, the thieves left smashed Christmas ornaments and a broken blanket ladder.
On Friday, a Tennessee appeals court upheld a lower court ruling finding Posey Storage Solutions and its owner, Tim Posey, liable for fraudulent misrepresentation, conversion, gross negligence and violations of the Tennessee Consumer Protection Act, among other claims. The court pointed to fake security cameras that Posey claimed were real and the fact he secretly held a second set of keys to the Dickeys’ rental units as reasons behind the judgment.
