Attorneys spar over conflicts of interest in Mountain City Club dispute
Staff photo by Matt Hamilton / Visitors enjoy an event at the Mountain City Club's location above the Gilman Grill in 2025. Attorneys on either side of a dispute involving ousted club leaders said in court documents filed in September that the other has a conflict of interest.
Two longtime Chattanooga attorneys have accused each other of conflicts of interest in a court case involving the ousted leaders of a 137-year-old social club who loaned $2 million to a local developer.
One of the attorneys, Neil Thomas, made an official motion to the Hamilton County Circuit Court to disqualify the opposing attorney in the case, William Horton. Horton is representing Mountain City Club’s new leaders and developer Jimmy White, who owes the club $2 million.
The club did not make the loan in an official capacity, according to court documents.
Chris Allen, the club’s former treasurer, loaned White the money from club funds in December through White’s personal business. Allen and Richard Johnson, the club’s former president, made the loan without the authorization of the club’s board or members, according to a lawsuit filed by the club and White in May.
Staff photo by Matt Hamilton / Attorneys on either side of a dispute involving ousted Mountain City Club leaders said in court documents filed in September that the other has a conflict of interest. A yacht called the Lady Helen, seen docked at the Erwin Marina near Ross’s Landing on April 8, 2026, is part of the case.Staff photo by Matt Hamilton / Attorneys on either side of a dispute involving ousted Mountain City Club leaders said in court documents filed in September that the other has a conflict of interest. A yacht called the Lady Helen, seen docked at the Erwin Marina near Ross’s Landing on April 8, 2026, is part of the case.Staff photo by Matt Hamilton / Richard Johnson speaks during an event at the Mountain City Club. Members voted in April 2026 to oust Johnson from his role as president. Attorneys on either side of a dispute involving ousted club leaders said in court documents in September that the other has a conflict of interest.Staff photo by Matt Hamilton / Visitors enjoy an event at the Mountain City Club’s location above the Gilman Grill in 2025. Attorneys on either side of a dispute involving ousted club leaders said in court documents filed in September that the other has a conflict of interest.Staff photo by Matt Hamilton / Visitors enjoy an event at the Mountain City Club’s location above the Gilman Grill in 2025. Attorneys on either side of a dispute involving ousted club leaders said in court documents filed in September that the other has a conflict of interest.
The court issued an order in May that White’s debt must be repaid to the club. Thomas argued in his motion to disqualify Horton on Sept. 1 that Horton should not represent the individual who owes the money and also the club he must pay back.
SUBSCRIBERS ONLY
This article is for subscribers
An active subscription is required to read this article. Subscribe for full access — or sign in if you already subscribe.