Skip to main content
Friday, November 20, 2026Nov 20

Community Voice: Christa Pike deserves life in prison, not execution

Nashville Banner File Photo/Martin B. Cherry / The Riverbend Maximum Security Institution in Nashville is pictured in 2025.
Nashville Banner File Photo/Martin B. Cherry / The Riverbend Maximum Security Institution in Nashville is pictured in 2025.

I know what it is to lose a child. There are losses that don’t simply hurt you but rearrange your life into a before and after, leaving you to learn how to live inside a world that has the audacity to keep moving. I know that grief because my son was murdered.

Before I say anything about Christa Pike, I want to say the name that must remain in this conversation: Colleen Slemmer. What happened to Colleen was horrific. She was 19 years old, had people who loved her and a future she should have been allowed to live. I would never ask Colleen’s family to forgive. Forgiveness is too personal to demand. I can tell you what I learned from my own grief. Hatred could not return my son to me. It could only make another grave inside a life wounded by loss, but it could not bring him home. For me, forgiveness became less about what someone else deserved and more about what I refused to let tragedy turn me into.

I also know what it means to be young inside the criminal justice system and to have adults decide who you are while you are still becoming a person. I entered the justice system at 16 for first-degree murder and aggravated robbery, facing a life sentence. The media assigned intent to me and narrated my story. I needed someone to say, “At the end of the day, she is still a child.” Instead, I learned how quickly a system can turn the worst thing connected to your name into your entire identity.

Today, I work with people affected by addiction, trauma and justice involvement. I have learned to look at the root of their actions, not just the result. Accountability and humanity were never supposed to be enemies. Christa was 18, and her co-defendant was 17. He received a life sentence and is now eligible for parole. Christa received a death sentence and faces execution on Sept. 30. Turning 18 does not magically complete a human being. Brain systems involved in judgment and impulse control continue developing into young adulthood. The difference between 17 and 18 matters on a birth certificate, but it does not create an entirely different brain overnight.

Christa’s childhood contained severe abuse, sexual violence, neglect and abandonment. Those facts do not excuse murder. They matter because context and excuses are not the same thing. The girl who was murdered deserved protection. The girl who grew up surrounded by violence deserved protection before she became capable of terrible violence herself. We failed them both in different ways.