“What if salvation is universal?” The priest held some silence, then repeated his question, this time with even more emphasis on “if.” I leaned back in my chair, arms crossed, and waited for it: God only saves Catholics, everyone else is doomed to hell. (Or maybe purgatory. I don’t know, I’m not Catholic).
But he continued: “If it is, I’d be overjoyed.” I sat up. “Sure, in part of my heart, I’d be making a list,” the priest half-joked. “Okay, maybe everyone… except him, or him.” But I’d be overjoyed.” He made some other points, I’m sure very good, but I was too stunned to take them in.
Here was a Catholic priest — a Jesuit, nonetheless — entertaining the idea that salvation might be universal. And he wrapped up like this: “What if salvation is universal? We don’t know. We can’t know. Maybe it is. Maybe it isn’t.”
Again, I’m not sure now what other points he made. I just couldn’t believe what I was hearing.
I grew up in churches that preached that only Christians go to heaven, and we must do all we can to save everyone from damnation. That’s a lot to put on anyone, especially a kid. For most of my life I thought that was a dogmatic, fundamental, core belief of Christianity. It’s part of the reason I didn’t go to church for five years. I just couldn’t deal with the idea that a loving God would sentence most of the world to death. And I definitely couldn’t deal with my failure to save even one of those souls from hell in all of my years.
