Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

New York puts UPS’s culture on trial in $873M cigarette case

This undated photo provided by the New York Office of the Attorney General and taken by state tax investigators shows the single-family home in Perrysburg, N.Y., out of which state regulators believe cigarette shipper Seneca Promotions operated. Prosecutors charge UPS should have known that Seneca Promotions was improperly sending freights of untaxed cigarettes from this location to tobacco distributors. But a UPS account executive testified the company was simply sending "office materials." (New York Office of the Attorney General via AP)
This undated photo provided by the New York Office of the Attorney General and taken by state tax investigators shows the single-family home in Perrysburg, N.Y., out of which state regulators believe cigarette shipper Seneca Promotions operated. Prosecutors charge UPS should have known that Seneca Promotions was improperly sending freights of untaxed cigarettes from this location to tobacco distributors. But a UPS account executive testified the company was simply sending "office materials." (New York Office of the Attorney General via AP)

NEW YORK (AP) – UPS was supposed to be looking for clues its brown trucks were being used to illegally transport untaxed cigarettes from upstate Indian reservations to customers throughout the state, but instead it turned a blind eye, say regulators, who’ve asked a judge to impose an $873 million penalty on it.

Over an eight-day federal civil trial headed for closing arguments Wednesday, city and state officials have argued that Atlanta-based United Parcel Service Inc., the nation’s largest delivery company, had a corporate culture that favored sales opportunities over a responsibility to help New York enforce tax law.

Tobacco retailers located on upstate reservations were given price discounts for shipping in volume. Delivery drivers were allowed to accept iPads and other gifts from shippers. Account executives, whose compensation was tied to keeping big accounts, ignored signs that some customers signing delivery contracts dealt in cigarettes.

One UPS customer, Seneca Promotions, operated from the same single-family home near Lake Erie as a well-known cigarette shipper, Native Wholesale Supply, and was sending tens of thousands of pounds of packages to businesses with names such as Tobaccoville and Tobacco Town, according to records filed in the court case.

“UPS must be held accountable,” lawyers for New York City and New York state wrote last month in a brief outlining what they said was a decade of misconduct. “It has inflicted widespread injury to the public health … by willfully blinding itself to known criminal activity.”