Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Court: No new trial after judge mistakenly declares mistrial

This undated photo provided by Fulton County Sheriff’s Office shows Geary Otis. A mistake by a superior court judge may set the Georgia man free without him ever having to stand trial for the stabbing death of a 75-year-old woman. (Fulton County Sheriff’s Office via AP)
This undated photo provided by Fulton County Sheriff’s Office shows Geary Otis. A mistake by a superior court judge may set the Georgia man free without him ever having to stand trial for the stabbing death of a 75-year-old woman. (Fulton County Sheriff’s Office via AP)

ATLANTA (AP) – A woman pleaded with the Georgia Supreme Court not to let the man accused of killing her mother go free because of a judge’s mistake before a jury can weigh his guilt or innocence.

The high court on Monday said a judge can’t set a new trial for Geary Otis after having erroneously declared a mistrial in his case nearly two years ago. Otis is charged with murder in the slaying of 75-year-old Mary Oliver and aggravated assault in an attack on 71-year-old Emmanuel Surry.

“It was a mistake on the judge’s behalf. By all means, sanction the judge and give it to another judge,” Oliver’s daughter Jan Jacobs said through tears at a news conference Tuesday. “But he should not walk free. What kind of message does that send if we just let murderers walk free?”

It all began June 17, 2013, when police said Geary Otis ran up the stairs of a high-rise apartment building for seniors and stabbed Surry before kicking down a metal door and fatally stabbing Oliver. Police had to use a stun gun to subdue him, according to court records.

Otis, who was 64 at the time, was a resident in the building but didn’t know Oliver or Surry, Fulton County District Attorney Paul Howard said. Oliver was asleep in her bed and Surry had just returned from taking his uncle to the hospital.