Skip to main content
Tuesday, November 17, 2026Nov 17

Georgia court allows lawsuit against sperm bank to proceed

Gavel tile / photo courtesy of Getty Images
Gavel tile / photo courtesy of Getty Images

ATLANTA (AP) – A couple who accused a sperm bank of misrepresenting its process for screening donors and providing incorrect medical and educational history of the donor they selected can proceed with a lawsuit against the sperm bank, Georgia’s highest court ruled Monday.

A Fulton County judge had dismissed all but one of the claims in the lawsuit the Normans had filed in November 2017 against the sperm bank, Xytex Corporation, and the intermediate appeals court, the Georgia Court of Appeals, had upheld that ruling.

The Georgia Supreme Court partially reversed that ruling, sending the case back to the trial court for some of the claims to be decided.

“It feels great and it’s justice,” said Nancy Hersh, an attorney for the couple, Wendy and Janet Norman.

Because the trial court dismissed the case at an early stage, the high court had to rely on “unproven allegations” by the plaintiffs, said Ted Lavender, an attorney for Xytex.