Skip to main content
Monday, November 9, 2026Nov 9

Illinois high court: Comcast must reveal anonymous commenter

This undated photo shows Bill Hadley, a menber of the Stephenson County, Ill., board. The Illinois Supreme Court affirmed Thursday, June 18, 2015, a lower court opinion ordering Comcast Cable Communications to identify a subscriber who posted an anonymous message suggesting a political candidate molests children. The court said Thursday that the internet service provider must identify the subscriber who commented on a 2011 article in the Freeport Journal Standard about Bill Hadley's candidacy for the Stephenson County board. Hadley filed a defamation lawsuit against the commenter and subpoenaed Comcast demanding that it identify the subscriber. (The Journal-Standard via AP)
This undated photo shows Bill Hadley, a menber of the Stephenson County, Ill., board. The Illinois Supreme Court affirmed Thursday, June 18, 2015, a lower court opinion ordering Comcast Cable Communications to identify a subscriber who posted an anonymous message suggesting a political candidate molests children. The court said Thursday that the internet service provider must identify the subscriber who commented on a 2011 article in the Freeport Journal Standard about Bill Hadley's candidacy for the Stephenson County board. Hadley filed a defamation lawsuit against the commenter and subpoenaed Comcast demanding that it identify the subscriber. (The Journal-Standard via AP) This undated photo shows Bill Hadley, a menber of the Stephenson County, Ill., board. The Illinois Supreme Court affirmed Thursday, June 18, 2015, a lower court opinion ordering Comcast Cable Communications to identify a subscriber who posted an anonymous message suggesting a political candidate molests children. The court said Thursday that the internet service provider must identify the subscriber who commented on a 2011 article in the Freeport Journal Standard about Bill Hadley's candidacy for the Stephenson County board. Hadley filed a defamation lawsuit against the commenter and subpoenaed Comcast demanding that it identify the subscriber. (The Journal-Standard via AP)

CHAMPAIGN, Ill. (AP) – Comcast Cable Communications must identify an internet-service subscriber who posted an anonymous message suggesting a political candidate molests children, the Illinois Supreme Court ruled Thursday, affirming a lower court opinion.

Potentially libelous online comments are an increasing source of concern. Commenters often hide behind the cloak of anonymity, seemingly untouchable. Don Craven, an attorney for the Illinois Press Association, said Thursday’s decision should make clear that Illinois, at least, will not tolerate such attempts at defamation.

The Comcast subscriber whose name must be revealed commented on a 2011 article in the Freeport Journal Standard about Bill Hadley’s candidacy for the Stephenson County board.

“Hadley is a Sandusky waiting to be exposed. Check out the view he has of Empire (Elementary School) from his front door,” wrote the commenter, who used the online name “Fuboy.” The comment was an apparent reference to former Penn State football coach Jerry Sandusky, who was convicted of child sex abuse in 2012.

Robert Fagan, a Freeport attorney who represents the commenter, declined comment, saying he hadn’t yet spoken to his client.