Skip to main content
Sunday, November 15, 2026Nov 15

Attorneys look at patient records in Life Care case

attorneys-look-at-patient-records-in-life
attorneys-look-at-patient-records-in-life
photo U.S. District Judge Harry S. “Sandy” Mattice

The federal judge overseeing a complex alleged Medicare fraud case against Life Care Centers of America had a simple question to begin Wednesday’s meeting.

“What’s this case about?” asked U.S. District Judge Harry S. “Sandy” Mattice.

The whistle-blower lawsuit against the private nursing home company with headquarters in Cleveland, Tenn., involves allegations of a “nationwide scheme” to bilk Medicare by charging for unnecessary services or overcharging for patient services, according to Assistant U.S. Attorney Elizabeth Tonkin.

Wednesday’s meeting was to begin sceduling court dates in the already four-year-old investigation. Documents were sealed and hearings closed before the Chattanooga Times Free Press requested access last year.

Tonkin told the judge that she and fellow prosecutors planned to take a sampling of 300 to 500 patient records at 60 to 80 of the company’s 225 facilities to obtain a statistical sample that would better simplify the case for trial.