Skip to main content
Monday, November 9, 2026Nov 9

Stephens: Meet a secret Trump supporter

Photo by Mark Makela of The New York Times / A supporter of President Donald Trump wears Trump-themed socks and shoes ahead of a presidential debate party hosted by Vice President Mike Pence, in Lititz, Pennsylvania, on Tuesday, Sept. 29, 2020.
Photo by Mark Makela of The New York Times / A supporter of President Donald Trump wears Trump-themed socks and shoes ahead of a presidential debate party hosted by Vice President Mike Pence, in Lititz, Pennsylvania, on Tuesday, Sept. 29, 2020. Photo by Mark Makela of The New York Times / A supporter of President Donald Trump wears Trump-themed socks and shoes ahead of a presidential debate party hosted by Vice President Mike Pence, in Lititz, Pennsylvania, on Tuesday, Sept. 29, 2020.

Chris is a registered Democrat in her 50s who lives in Manhattan. She’s well-educated, well-traveled and well-informed. She has voted for candidates of both parties over the years and was enthusiastic for Bernie Sanders in 2016.

She’s asked me not to publish her last name. It would not go down well for her at the store where she works as a manager if her colleagues knew that she plans to vote for Donald Trump.

Chris is also gay. “Being a lesbian who’s voting for Trump is like coming out of the closet again,” she tells me.

Readers of The New York Times who conjure an image of a Trump voter probably think of people like Mark and Patricia McCloskey, the couple who pointed guns at protesters outside their St. Louis home in late June. But if Trump defies current polling and wins again, it’ll be thanks to a discreet base of support from voters like Chris, who fit into none of the cultural or demographic stereotypes of the Trump base.

It’s worth understanding where she’s coming from.