Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Dayton’s Cumberland Cafe delivers on promise of ‘fresh, local, good’

Baked Mediterranean chicken is the signature entree at Cumberland Cafe & Market in Dayton, Tenn. Marinated chicken is cooked with olives and spices in a brown sugar wine sauce and served atop white rice.
Baked Mediterranean chicken is the signature entree at Cumberland Cafe & Market in Dayton, Tenn. Marinated chicken is cooked with olives and spices in a brown sugar wine sauce and served atop white rice.
photo Blueberry buttermilk pie was a recent dessert of the day at Cumberland Cafe & Market in Dayton, Tenn.

If you go

› What: Cumberland Cafe & Market, 1368 Market St., Dayton, Tenn.› Phone: 423-834-9888› Website: cumberlandcafeandmarket.com› Hours: 11 a.m.-2:30 p.m. Monday- Friday (market open until 6 p.m.); Friday night dinners start at 5:30 p.m.› Price range: $6.95-$9.50 (lunch menu)

The first time I wandered in to Cumberland Cafe & Market in Dayton, Tenn., was an after-hours visit during the Holiday Stroll among downtown merchants back in November. Goods from the market portion of the business were available: breads, cheeses, grab-and-go pasta and potato salads. The kitchen, alas, was closed.

But the place looked welcoming, the menu looked promising, and I vowed to return for lunch. I got a chance last week, and now I’m looking for another opportunity to go back to Rhea County.

THE MENU

The menu isn’t extensive, but the choices are varied with a promise of foods that are “fresh, local, good.” There are the usual sandwiches – tuna salad, turkey breast, Philly cheese – plus pimento cheese with sliced tomato, a Southern classic. Both meatloaf and slow-braised pork barbecue are available as entrees or sandwiches. And something called the Best Quesadilla Ever is begging to be tried.