Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

How the anti-vaccine movement pits parental rights against public health

Barb Dentz, right, an advocate with Tennessee Families for Vaccines, met with her state representative, Rep. Sam Whitson, R-Franklin, to discuss the state's declining childhood immunization rates in January. (Amy Maxmen/KFF Health News)
Barb Dentz, right, an advocate with Tennessee Families for Vaccines, met with her state representative, Rep. Sam Whitson, R-Franklin, to discuss the state's declining childhood immunization rates in January. (Amy Maxmen/KFF Health News)

Gayle Borne has fostered more than 300 children in Springfield, Tennessee. She’s cared for children who have rarely seen a doctor — youngsters so neglected they cannot speak.

Such children are now even more vulnerable because of a law Tennessee passed last year that requires the direct consent of birth parents or legal guardians for every routine childhood vaccination. Foster parents, social workers and other caregivers cannot provide permission.

In January, Borne took a foster baby, born extremely premature at just over 2 pounds, to her first doctor’s appointment. The health providers said that without the consent of the child’s mother, they couldn’t vaccinate her against diseases like pneumonia, hepatitis B and polio. The mother hasn’t been located, so a social worker is now seeking a court order to permit immunizations.

“We are just waiting,” Borne said. “Our hands are tied.”

Tennessee’s law has also stymied grandmothers and other caregivers who accompany children to routine appointments when parents are at work, in drug and alcohol rehabilitation clinics or otherwise unavailable. The law claims to “give parents back the right to make medical decisions for their children.”