Skip to main content
Thursday, October 29, 2026Oct 29

This story is free to read.

Athens, Tennessee, council member faces ouster suit following Tuesday vote

Screenshot / In a screenshot of a livestreamed Athens City Council meeting, Athens Mayor Steve Sherlin, left, speaks to longtime council member Dick Pelley on Tuesday about Pelley's potential ouster over a project allegedly launched without approval. The council voted 4-1 to pursue an ouster suit against Pelley in court. Pelley cast the opposing vote.
Screenshot / In a screenshot of a livestreamed Athens City Council meeting, Athens Mayor Steve Sherlin, left, speaks to longtime council member Dick Pelley on Tuesday about Pelley's potential ouster over a project allegedly launched without approval. The council voted 4-1 to pursue an ouster suit against Pelley in court. Pelley cast the opposing vote. Screenshot / In a screenshot of a livestreamed Athens City Council meeting, Athens Mayor Steve Sherlin, left, speaks to longtime council member Dick Pelley on Tuesday about Pelley's potential ouster over a project allegedly launched without approval. The council voted 4-1 to pursue an ouster suit against Pelley in court. Pelley cast the opposing vote.


Longtime Athens City Council member Dick Pelley will face ouster proceedings following a 4-1 vote during a short meeting at city hall Tuesday on allegations regarding his conduct as an elected official.

Pelley, a member of the city council since 2002, was the lone no vote on whether to bring an ouster lawsuit. He is accused in an internal investigation of starting a municipal flag project at the city’s veteran’s park without discussion or coordination with city staff or fellow council members, according to a report by city attorney Chris Caldwell.

Caldwell reported his findings to the council on June 18, saying Pelley’s alleged overreach exposed the city and other parties involved to liabilities because the project was uninsured, unapproved and unofficial. Caldwell told the panel Pelley’s actions violate a state law applying to anyone holding an office of trust or profit who commits “any act constituting a violation of any penal statute involving moral turpitude.”

Pelley told fellow council members he wanted to have the hearing immediately on Tuesday.