Skip to main content
Saturday, November 14, 2026Nov 14

ObamaCare in court

This is the week when a federal judge in Florida begins hearing arguments by 20 states that the ObamaCare socialized medicine law is unconstitutional.

Conservative states such as Alabama and Georgia, but also liberal states such as Washington, will argue in court that nowhere in the Constitution is power delegated to Congress to force Americans to purchase health insurance. Nor may Congress force the states to spend billions more of their own tax dollars to provide care.

The states are correct in seeking to overturn ObamaCare. The Constitution strictly limits the powers of the federal government. Washington may properly perform functions such as national defense and the printing of currency, for example. But it may not dictate that the American people must purchase congressionally approved medical insurance – under penalty of big fines for those who do not buy the insurance.

In the Florida lawsuit, the 20 state attorneys general criticized the Obama administration’s misuse of the Constitution’s Commerce Clause in its defense of ObamaCare. They said it is absurd that the Commerce Clause could be used to punish people for not engaging in commerce.

The mandate that a person buy insurance “rests upon the incredible contention that inactivity – the failure to have health insurance – constitutes economic activity,” they argued.