These perverse ideologues, warped theocrats. They may be able to inspire a single lone wolf to commit a savage act, but they can never, never threaten who we are.
U.S. Vice President Joe Biden began with a wish.
As he stood on stage at McKenzie Arena during a solemn ceremony for the five men who died when a gunman attacked two military sites in Chattanooga on July 16, Biden looked at the families of the dead.
"I wish that I was not here," he said, quietly and slowly. "For I have some sense of how hard it is for you to be here."
Hanging at UALR
on Friday, February 22
Biden's 46-year-old son died in May, and the vice president seemed to channel his own grief as he addressed the families of the men who died in Chattanooga after the attack one month ago today: Sgt. Carson Holmquist, 25, Gunnery Sgt. Thomas Sullivan, 40, Lance Cpl. Squire "Skip" Wells, 21, Staff Sgt. David Wyatt, 35, and U.S. Navy Petty Officer 2nd Class Randall Smith, 26.
At times he spoke barely above a whisper, but at other moments he shouted, voice booming over the national officials, military service members and hundreds of locals there to honor the fallen Marines and sailor.
Biden ignored the careful rhetoric of FBI investigators, who have refused to call gunman Mohammad Youssef Abdulazeez a terrorist or say he was motivated by extreme Islam. Instead, Biden placed the attack squarely in the center of America's war on terror by labeling Abdulazeez a "perverted jihadist" and warned America's enemies the nation will not back down.
"These perverse ideologues, warped theocrats," he said. "They may be able to inspire a single lone wolf to commit a savage act, but they can never, never threaten who we are. When this perverted jihadist struck, everyone responded."
He praised the service members, law enforcement and first responders for their actions that day but spent most of his 20-minute speech addressing the families of the men who died and praising the men's dedication to their country. He repeatedly called Islamic extremists "cowards" and vowed that the nation would not be moved.
"America never yields, never bends," he said. "Never cowers, never stands down. Endures, responds and always overcomes. Because we are Americans. And never, never underestimate us."
The crowd gave him a standing ovation as he left the stage. The majority of the arena was empty, with only a fraction of the 8,500 available seats filled.
The poor turnout was an about-face from the earliest days after the attack, when thousands of flag-toting locals lined miles of Chattanooga streets during the funeral processions for Wyatt and Smith. More thousands visited the makeshift memorials at the shooting sites to pay their respects and churches overflowed during vigils.
But few turned up Saturday. People who did attend blamed the traffic, the weather or the tight security for the lackluster turnout. Parts of Interstate 75, U.S. Highway 27, state Highway 153 and several roads downtown were halted or closed altogether at times Saturday, bringing traffic in the area to a standstill.
Some attendees said they showed up expecting to be turned away because the arena was full and were surprised to find ample space. Perhaps, they said, the expectation of a full house kept people at home.
"I was disappointed," said attendee Todd Larson. "We were hoping we were going to pack the place. Show the families our support. I think 30 days past, it's lost some of the momentum. But they're still in our hearts."
Biden spoke after a handful of local and national officials first took the stage, including U.S. Secretary of Defense Ashton Carter and Secretary of the Navy Ray Mabus. Mayor Andy Berke also spoke, outlining the city's initial horror and subsequent response to the shootings.
"Despite the darkness of the past 30 days, there is yet light," Berke said. "One chapter has ended, but we have begun a new chapter. The world has seen our character."
Lt. Cmdr. Tim White, the Navy officer who used his personal weapon to fire at Abdulazeez as the gunman ran into the U.S. Naval and Marine Reserve on Amnicola Highway, described the day of the attack when he took the stage.
"Calmness, rustling leaves, screeching tires, gunfire - those were the sounds of July 16, 2015," he said. "Sounds that transformed a beautiful summer morning into a day filled with tragedy and tears. Sounds that few heard, but will never be forgotten."
At the very end of the emotional service, First Sgt. John Coyne took a final roll call. Standing before the crowd, he called the names of five service members who were there. Each man stood and shouted, "Present."
Then he called the names of the men who died.
"Gunnery Sgt. Sullivan," he said.
"Gunnery Sgt. Thomas Sullivan," he repeated.
"Gunnery Sgt. Thomas J. Sullivan."
He called each name three times. Wyatt. Holmquist. Smith. Wells.
"That name, it was a beating heart," said attendee Harriet Berman. "And that heart is no longer beating."
After each call, there was only silence.
Contact staff writer Shelly Bradbury at sbrad firstname.lastname@example.org or 423-757-6525 with tips or story ideas.
Read more about the attacks on Chattanooga military facilities
DesJarlais' bill to allow military to carry firearms at recruiting centers passes Senate
Tennessee National Guard recruiters likely to reoccupy storefront locations next week after post-July attack upgrades
Memorial concert for fallen Marine Skip Wells this Saturday
Charleston, Chattanooga joined by tragedy, love
Instinct, basic training helped Marine save daughter during July 16 attack
Cooper: Marine Corps report revelations strengthen need for carry policy
Chattanooga Heroes Fund exceeds $1 million in donations
U.S. Women's World Cup team raises $60,000 to benefit the Chattanooga Heroes Fund
Chattanooga gunman test drove Lexus convertible before July 16 attack
Crowds pack Ross's Landing for tribute to five slain servicemen
Two months after July 16 attack, many questions remain unanswered
Jackson returns to hometown for today's tribute to five fallen heroes
Trace Adkins, Colt Ford, Aaron Lewis added to Chattanooga Unite benefit
Greeson: Chattanooga Unite offers all of us a chance to remember
July 16 shooter had no hard drugs in his system during April DUI arrest, lab results show
U.S. Marines will not arm recruiters in wake of July 16 attack
Photos: Run of Honor benefit race
Harry Connick Jr. added to Chattanooga United event
Kennedy: Angels of the flag garden
Tribute rises: Massive sculpture celebrates lives of Chattanooga's five fallen heroes
Greeson: UTC to honor five military heroes from July 16
Cook: Grief and the violence of July 16
Navy launches official investigation into Chattanooga attack
Bob Corker warns 'dramatically changing' lives in response to Chattanooga shootings sends wrong signal
New bill would grant immunity to armed TN National Guard members
Muslims lead donations to families in Chattanooga shooting at Nashville event
Samuel Jackson to emcee benefit concert for July 16 attack victims
Makeshift Lee Highway memorial to servicemen cleared
Permanent memorial to slain servicemen on Lee Highway
A gunman warped our history, now we must shape our future
Vice President Joe Biden honors Chattanooga shooting victim and promises: 'America never yields'
Chattanooga slayings prompt state, federal changes on military members being armed in U.S.
The moment the call comes in: responding to an active shooter
Berke: Moments of crisis revealed Chattanooga character
Chattanooga Can Build On Unity
Biden calls shooter 'perverted jihadist' at memorial in Chattanooga
Chattanooga holds memorial service for fallen service members
Biden to speak at Chattanooga memorial service, security heightened
Pam's Points: Weekend of tributes can lead to healing
Concert to benefit shooting victim's families Sept. 16
Details falling into place for Biden visit, memorial to Chattanooga's fallen heroes
Greeson: A weekend filled with reasons to forever remember all our heroes
Secret Service orders all Chattanooga traffic cameras to go dark Saturday
Photos: UTC retires flag that flew at half-staff in mourning for Chattanooga's fallen five
Vice president to attend ceremony honoring five fallen military servicemen
Sixty-five-foot-tall sculpture will commemorate victims of July 16 attack
Tennessee Senate Republicans: Radical Islam is the enemy
Cruz says if he becomes president he'll stop trend of 'radical Islamic terrorism'
Memorial for slain servicemen to be held Saturday
Tennessee National Guard has $18 million in needed security upgrades for armories, recruiting centers, motor pools
Top Pentagon brass to attend one-month anniversary of Chattanooga attacks
Wiedmer: World Cuppers' exhibition can still help our fallen heroes
Kimball approves assistance donations, including Chattanooga Heroes Fund
Chattanooga Sings for Hope concert raises money for victims' families
Motorcyclists go on charity ride to honor slain Marine
An open letter to Chattanooga from Adm. Jonathan W. Greenert
Healing but scarred: Marine wounded in July 16 attack back to recruiting
Hundreds in Arkansas gather to remember slain Marine Staff Sgt. David Wyatt
Permanent memorial will be dedicated on one-month anniversary of July 16 attacks
Navy plans to station armed guards at reserve centers across U.S.
Some recruiters will be packing 9 mm handguns under new Tennessee guidelines
Guardsmen with valid permits can now carry guns at facilities
FBI scales back its presence in Chattanooga following July 16 rampage
GOP pushes back on 'politically correct' labeling of extremist attacks
Wiedmer: Let U.S. Soccer be a Chattanooga hero
Local artist to paint mural honoring slain military servicemen
Chattanooga Sings For Hope concert remembers the fallen, honors first responders
Al-Qaida calls for more lone wolf attacks, praises Chattanooga shooter
Haslam: Most Americans wouldn't resent serviceman for shooting at Abdulazeez
Petition to honor servicemen who fired personal weapons at Chattanooga gunman hits 20,000 signatures
Navy: Officer has not been charged for firing personal weapon at Chattanooga gunman
An offering of art: Illinois artist responds to Chattanooga shootings
After July 16, tragedy became politics
What's in a name? The absence of terror label after attacks sparks national debate
Ali: Mentally disturbed, Muslim criminal
Tragedy brought out best of Chattanooga says an appreciative WWII, Korean War vet and other letters to the editors
Families of the five slain military servicemen receive donation of nearly $120,000
July 16 tragedy united community and brought out Chattanooga's best
Charitable cottage industry springs up in wake of shooting rampage
Navy officer confirms he shot at Abdulazeez with his personal weapon
Bond between Chattanooga, Port Angeles grows: 'It's almost like we're sister cities'
Business Bulletin: Fundraiser scams hit Chattanooga area in wake of tragedy
Insane Paintball/Airsoft game benefits Chattanooga shooting victims fund
Defense secretary calls for review of security policies in wake of Chattanooga shootings
Port Angeles woman presents Chattanooga mayor with 20 sympathy banners
White House petitioned to honor Chattanooga servicemen who fired back at gunman
Chattanooga Freedom Float planned to raise money for heroes in July 16 attack
FBI, NCIS search banks of Tennessee River off River Canyon Road
Chattanooga Marines return to work after attack
Port Angeles group hand-carries 16 signed sympathy banners to Chattanooga
Last of the five slain military servicemen is laid to rest at National Cemetery
The funerals are over, but closure is ongoing
Dropkick Murphys honor fallen Massachusetts Marine
See the DUI arrest of Chattanooga gunman Mohammad Abdulazeez
Hits 96 honoring slain service members with concert featuring MKTO and Karmin
Public lines up to honor Petty Officer 2nd Class Randall Smith
Gunnery Sgt. Thomas Sullivan is laid to rest in Massachusetts hometown
Fleischmann announces bill to award Purple Hearts to shooting victims
Are we helping extremists recruit our lost children?
No easy answers forthcoming when the mind's involved
Funeral procession for Navy Petty Officer Randall Smith announced
Funeral held for Chattanooga shooting victim Sgt. Thomas Sullivan
The youngest hero: Thousands gather for funeral of Skip Wells
Bravo Network star visits Chattanooga, lends some of her ample strength to wounded community
Smith: Beauty through Brokenness – Chattanooga's Choice
'His life made a difference,' Hundreds mourn Atlanta Marine slain in Chattanooga
After the vigils, the real work begins
Homegrown: The new threat to America comes from within
As threats to Muslims mount, Pentagon asks civilians to stand down
Mother of Sgt. David Allen Wyatt says thanks to Chattanooga
Gerber: A national tragedy in our backyard
Healing Chattanooga, one life and brick at a time
Chattanooga will prevail after tragedy and other letters to the editors
Visitation continues for Cpl. Squire 'Skip' Wells; 2nd Class Randall Smith's body in Nashville
Wisconsin town says goodbye to Marine slain in Chattanooga
Pentagon asks armed volunteers to stop guarding U.S. military recruiting centers
Multitudes gather to mourn and honor fallen Marine Staff Sgt. David Wyatt
Baptists show support by visiting local Mosque for Friday prayers
Greeson: Elected officials should start planning memorial
Body of slain Massachusetts Marine returns home
Mourners gather to pay respects to slain Georgia Marine
Tennessee River 600 to honor fallen servicemen on Sunday
Body of slain Marine being laid to rest at Chattanooga's National Cemetery
Funeral arrangements made for Navy Petty Officer Randall Smith
Military Times: Marine Corps confirms Purple Hearts prepared for Marines killed last week in Chattanooga
Mike Battery Marines recount heroic actions during rampage at Amnicola reserve center
'Run!' Quick response key to survival in first attack at recruitment office
Funeral for Staff Sgt. Wyatt is today; public invited to line roadside along procession route
Cook: Four poems about the last seven days shared to ease city's pain
Chattanooga's broad middle helps city bear tragedy
Gunning for safety? Military leaders say no
Peyton Manning adds muscle to fundraising for families of shooting victims
Tennessee ramps up handgun permitting for Guard, but can they bring firearms to work?
Friends rally around Hindu businessman subjected to nasty Facebook gossip
Moment of radio silence held in remembrance of service members killed
Mississippi National Guard recruiters returning to 10 sites
Civilian accidentally fires AR-15 rifle at Ohio military recruiting station
Navy has memorial in Virginia for Tennessee shooting victim
Marines moved citizens in the Riverpark away from shooter
Four misconceptions about the Chattanooga shooting
Tennessee lawmakers to meet next month to assess the state's security status after Haslam directives
Jordan releases uncle of Chattanooga gunman without filing any charges
Funeral plans set for all five slain service members
City Beat: I'm thankful cops sometimes go against human nature
Tunes for tragic times: Sad songs say so much
Hixson Flight Museum plans flight flight to salute fallen Marines and sailor
FBI searches woods at intersection of Highway 153 and Amnicola
Chattanooga declares shooting sites, funerals and memorials off-limits to protesters
Lance Cpl. Skip Wells' body to be escorted this afternoon
Peyton Manning launches Chattanooga Heroes Fund to honor shooting victims
Sgt. Thomas J. Sullivan to be buried in hometown
Minute by minute: A timeline of the Chattanooga attack revealed
Terrorist or extremist, was Abdulazeez a man with a plan?
Gov. Haslam moves National Guard recruiting offices to armories
Clipping and snipping, volunteers prepare donated flowers for Marine's last rites
'Best Town Ever' rival reaches out in sympathy to Chattanooga
Greeson: Reason why we are the Best Town Ever -- all of you
City's church bells to chime on one-week anniversary of shooting
Video: Five of the Marines who survived Chattanooga attack tell their story
Kentucky to enhance security at National Guard bases and recruitment offices
Ohio starts to arm recruiters in wake of Chattanooga attack
Tennessee moves recruiters to National Guard armories
Armed citizens flock to recruiting centers to stand guard
FBI explains how Chattanooga shooting played out, how Mohammad Abdulazeez was killed
Corker gets choked up, pauses in Senate while honoring slain servicemembers
Armed citizens flock to recruiting centers to stand guard
Port Angeles residents sign giant card for Chattanooga after deadly shootings
Pentagon rejects calls to arm all U.S.-based military personnel
FBI calls Chattanooga shooter a homegrown violent extremist
After Chattanooga shootings, armed citizens guard recruiters
How will last week's attack affect Chattanooga's brand?
'Mike Battery is here': After loss, Marines regroup, move forward
Fighting for our fighters: Erlanger trauma team called to front lines on day of shootings
'God bless these American heroes,' Obama says in day of tribute, remembrance for fallen
Marietta, Ga., residents honor hometown hero killed in tragic attack
Duke's basketball coach provides 'bright spot' for fallen sailor's family
Services set for two slain Marines
'I don't think they were involved,' neighbor says after FBI raids Mountain Creek Apartments residence
Cook: The universal wound of Lee Highway
The more we learn, the less we understand
Gov. Walker issues order to arm Wisconsin National Guard
In West Virginia, 2 armed men stand outside recruiting center
Virginia governor asks for more patrols at recruiting centers
Crowd gathers to mourn Georgia victim in Chattanooga attack
Navy officer, Marine shot at Chattanooga gunman, according to report
Council seeks to ban protesters from funerals of five slain servicemen
Flags at half-staff in South Carolina, again
Chattanooga mayor: we owe these five heroes and their families a deep debt of gratitude
FBI raids apartment of Muslim family at Mountain Creek Apartments
Shooter's family denies reports that Jordanian uncle is tied to Chattanooga attack
Obituary for Sgt. Carson Holmquist
Two slain servicemembers will be laid to rest in Chattanooga
Chattanooga shootings photo galleries
Supercuts stores in Chattanooga offer special haircut prices for military and police
Alabama sheriff urges citizens to take up arms to defend against lone wolf attacks
Marine Corps trainee sees man shot, pulls over and stops bleeding
Obama orders flags flown at half-staff
President, senators honor shooting victims
UPDATED: Lawyer says Chattanooga shooter's uncle detained
Abdulazeez followed a radical member of al Qaeda
Flags lowered at U.S. Capitol, Obama could lower White House flags today
Armed volunteers guard Murfreesboro recruiting center
Makeshift memorials grow as a city moves through waves of grief
Local gun sales spike after attacks on military sites in Chattanooga
Answers elusive as different sides of Mohammad Abdulazeez's life emerge
Because of his love for city, Marine's family wants him to be buried at Chattanooga National Cemetery
Public Defender Steve Smith stands by Facebook comments following attacks
Fleischmann 'disappointed' because White House hasn't lowered U.S. flag
Cook: The semantics of terrorism and the quest for peace
Looking for peace? Don't ask Steve Smith
Tweak gun policy for military installations
DesJarlais: Bill arming military personnel needed because Pentagon directive falls short
U.S. flag sales soar in Chattanooga after shooting
Two area legislators issue call for action on slaying of four Marines, sailor in Chattanooga
Military directs security upgrades at facilities after Chattanooga shootings
Gov. Bryant OKs Mississippi Guard to arm personnel
Chattanooga shooting prompts Nebraska Guard to arm personnel
Chattanooga attack was an act of terror, Rep. Chuck Fleischmann says
Republicans ask Missouri governor to arm National Guard
Shooter's diary paints a disturbing picture
Arkansas governor temporarily closes state's nine National Guard recruitment offices
South Carolina joins other states in arming National Guardsmen
Iowa to review security at National Guard facilities in wake of Chattanooga attacks
Madisonville man arrested at Lee Highway memorial
Muslim blogger quoted by gunman in yearbook speaks out
U.S. military tells recruiting centers to step up security by closing blinds
One of the Marines killed Thursday may have carried a privately owned Glock
Crowd awaits Westboro Baptist protesters at Chattanooga shooting memorial on Lee Hwy.
DesJarlais, Cohen co-introduce bipartisan 'Enhancing Safety at Military Installations Act''; other TN congressmen sign on
Tennessee representative calls gunman Mohammad Youssef Abdulazeez a 'jihadi'
Flags to remain at half-staff until sunset on Friday
Wiedmer: Peyton a welcome visitor for our town's finest
Honoring the dead: Rally, memorial, hearse motorcade pay respects to shooting victims
Homeland Security committee chairman: 'If it can happen in Chattanooga, it can happen anywhere, anytime, anyplace'
Gov. Bill Haslam orders Tennessee officials to provide more protections for state National Guard following Chattanooga shooting
Governor Haslam orders review of safety measures at Tennessee military facilities
FBI looking into shooter's possible involvement with ISIS
Hundreds rally in motorcade for the shooting victims
Family spokesman: Depression dogged Chattanooga gunman
Friends mourn U.S. Navy Petty Officer 2nd Class Randall Smith, shot to death in Chattanooga shooting
Cook: In the big heart of Chattanooga
Family of dead Chattanooga gunman breaks silence
Marine commander: 'Heroic acts by our Marines on that day'
Will the shooting change life for Chattanooga Muslims?
Tennessee pauses as other states quickly arm Guardsmen in wake of Chattanooga attacks
Friends say Chattanooga shooter was changed by trip to Middle East
Father of Chattanooga shooter says he was blindsided by son's actions
Westboro Baptist reportedly planning to protest funerals of slain servicemen, locals plan counter protest
Indiana, Florida, Texas, Arkansas, Oklahoma, Louisiana to arm Guardsmen in wake of Chattanooga shootings
Chattanooga Muslims anxious after shootings
Chattanoogans puzzling out answers, pouring out grief
Semper Fi: Remembering the fallen in the Chattanooga attacks
DesJarlais, others say gun restrictions should be lifted at military buildings
Groups raising funds for shooting victims, families
Greeson: Trying to comprehend incomprehensible acts
Chattanooga shock moves to soul-searching
Front lines collided in Thursday's horror
Wiedmer: Former Red Bank student's acts leave ex-wrestling teammates in shock
More than 1,000 attend interfaith memorial service for slain Marines
Remains of fallen Marines to be given same honors as those killed in action
Shooter worked at nuclear power plant before failing background check
U.S. House Chairman says Chattanooga slayings now officially a terrorism investigation
Shooter came from troubled family, divorce papers show
Slain Marine's last text to his girlfriend warned of gunman's assault
DesJarlais plans bill allowing qualified military personnel to carry sidearms at military installations
Fallen Heroes: What we know about the four men who gave all for their country
Who was Mohammad Youssef Abdulazeez?
UTC students, local community mourn at prayer vigil
Minute-by-minute coverage of the Chattanooga shooting that killed four Marines
Chattanoogans reach out on Instagram after tragic shooting
Timeline of terror in Chattanooga shootings
Community grieves, gathers for prayers in wake of tragedy
Nightmare for city: Federal investigation vowed after four Marines killed in shooting
Sympathy for victims pours in following Chattanooga shootings
Eyewitnesses recount moments of violent tragedy
Latest national news on Chattanooga shootings: authorities searching gunman's computer
Cook: On a normal Thursday morning, everything changed
Tragedy will not define us, our city will heal