Skip to main content
Wednesday, November 11, 2026Nov 11

Time will tell if furling the rebel flag means deeper change

FILE - In this Saturday, June 27, 2015 file photo, Dan Williams, 65, of Ashville, Ala., holds a Confederate flag while standing with his daughter Bonnie-Blue Williams, 15, in front of the Alabama State Capitol building during a Confederate flag rally in Montgomery, Ala. Across the South, Confederate symbols are toppling or teetering or at least getting critical new looks. But is it a sign of real change in a region known for defending its complex traditions, or simply the work of frightened politicians and nervous corporate bean counters scrambling for cover in the wake of another white-on-black atrocity? (Albert Cesare/The Montgomery Advertiser via AP, File)  NO SALES; MANDATORY CREDIT: ALBERT CESARE/THE MONTGOMERY ADVERTISER
FILE - In this Saturday, June 27, 2015 file photo, Dan Williams, 65, of Ashville, Ala., holds a Confederate flag while standing with his daughter Bonnie-Blue Williams, 15, in front of the Alabama State Capitol building during a Confederate flag rally in Montgomery, Ala. Across the South, Confederate symbols are toppling or teetering or at least getting critical new looks. But is it a sign of real change in a region known for defending its complex traditions, or simply the work of frightened politicians and nervous corporate bean counters scrambling for cover in the wake of another white-on-black atrocity? (Albert Cesare/The Montgomery Advertiser via AP, File) NO SALES; MANDATORY CREDIT: ALBERT CESARE/THE MONTGOMERY ADVERTISER FILE - In this Saturday, June 27, 2015 file photo, Dan Williams, 65, of Ashville, Ala., holds a Confederate flag while standing with his daughter Bonnie-Blue Williams, 15, in front of the Alabama State Capitol building during a Confederate flag rally in Montgomery, Ala. Across the South, Confederate symbols are toppling or teetering or at least getting critical new looks. But is it a sign of real change in a region known for defending its complex traditions, or simply the work of frightened politicians and nervous corporate bean counters scrambling for cover in the wake of another white-on-black atrocity? (Albert Cesare/The Montgomery Advertiser via AP, File) NO SALES; MANDATORY CREDIT: ALBERT CESARE/THE MONTGOMERY ADVERTISER

BIRMINGHAM, Ala. (AP) – Across the South, Confederate symbols are toppling, teetering or at least getting critical new looks. But is it a sign of real change in a region known for fiercely defending its complex traditions, or simply the work of frightened politicians and nervous corporate bean counters scrambling for cover in the wake of another white-on-black atrocity?

Probably a bit of both, says author Tracy Thompson. “But, so what?”

“I’m sure there’s a lot of expedient backtracking going on,” said Thompson, who wrote “The New Mind of the South.” “If it’s going in the right direction, who cares?”

One who does care is the Rev. Joseph Darby – a longtime friend of Clementa Pinckney, one of nine slain during a Bible study at a black church in Charleston, South Carolina. And he thinks it’s a bit premature to declare this a new “New South,” as some commentators have suggested.

“Taking down those flags is not that big a deal,” he said of Gov. Nikki Haley’s call to remove the Confederate battle flag from the statehouse lawn and Alabama Gov. Robert Bentley’s order Wednesday to take down four rebel banners from a memorial at his capitol. Some citizens have long taken offense to the flags, which they associate with racial conflict.