Skip to main content
Thursday, November 12, 2026Nov 12

Lawyer: Officer thought Castile resembled robbery suspect

After listening to speakers in front of the St. Anthony Police Department, participants marched north on Silver Lake Rd. to 39th Ave. NE and then returned to where they started. A few hundred demonstrators protested peacefully on Silver Lake Rd. NE in front of the St. Anthony Police Department headquarters Sunday afternoon, July 10, 2016 in St. Anthony. (Jeff Wheeler/Star Tribune via AP)
After listening to speakers in front of the St. Anthony Police Department, participants marched north on Silver Lake Rd. to 39th Ave. NE and then returned to where they started. A few hundred demonstrators protested peacefully on Silver Lake Rd. NE in front of the St. Anthony Police Department headquarters Sunday afternoon, July 10, 2016 in St. Anthony. (Jeff Wheeler/Star Tribune via AP) After listening to speakers in front of the St. Anthony Police Department, participants marched north on Silver Lake Rd. to 39th Ave. NE and then returned to where they started. A few hundred demonstrators protested peacefully on Silver Lake Rd. NE in front of the St. Anthony Police Department headquarters Sunday afternoon, July 10, 2016 in St. Anthony. (Jeff Wheeler/Star Tribune via AP)

MINNEAPOLIS (AP) – A lawyer for a Minnesota police officer who shot a black driver has said his client thought he was approaching someone who resembled a suspect in an armed robbery – an assertion that could be pivotal as investigators review how the deadly traffic stop went down.

But outside observers say that claim raises some questions. Among them: If the officer suspected Philando Castile in the robbery, why didn’t he treat the traffic stop as a potentially dangerous situation?

“There’s something inconsistent about what happened here,” said Albert Goins, a Minnesota attorney who is not representing anyone in the case. “That inconsistency has got to be answered.”

St. Anthony police officer Jeronimo Yanez shot Castile on Wednesday in the St. Paul suburb of Falcon Heights. Castile’s death – and another police shooting a day earlier in Baton Rouge, Louisiana, that also left a black man dead – prompted protests around the country, including in Dallas where five officers were killed and several more were wounded Thursday. Protesters have been camped out in front of the Minnesota governor’s mansion for days, demanding justice, while dozens were arrested after a weekend march shut down a 6-mile stretch of freeway.

As the investigation into Castile’s death proceeds, those following the case are left to sort through conflicting accounts and questions about how Yanez and fellow officer Joseph Kauser handled the traffic stop. Authorities released no new information about the case Monday, and wouldn’t answer questions about the traffic stop, citing data privacy laws.