Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Hulk Hogan sex-video verdict could have limited impact

Hulk Hogan, whose given name is Terry Bollea, center, looks on in court moments after a jury returned its decision Monday, March 21, 2016, in St. Petersburg, Fla. A jury has hit Gawker Media with $15 million in punitive damages and its owner with $10 million, adding to the $115 million it awarded last week for publishing a sex video of Hogan. (Dirk Shadd/The Tampa Bay Times via AP, Pool) NEW YORK POST OUT
Hulk Hogan, whose given name is Terry Bollea, center, looks on in court moments after a jury returned its decision Monday, March 21, 2016, in St. Petersburg, Fla. A jury has hit Gawker Media with $15 million in punitive damages and its owner with $10 million, adding to the $115 million it awarded last week for publishing a sex video of Hogan. (Dirk Shadd/The Tampa Bay Times via AP, Pool) NEW YORK POST OUT
photo Hulk Hogan, whose given name is Terry Bollea, speaks to the media after a jury returned its decision Monday, March 21, 2016, in St. Petersburg, Fla. A jury has hit Gawker Media with $15 million in punitive damages and its owner with $10 million, adding to the $115 million it awarded last week for publishing a sex video of Hogan. (Dirk Shadd/The Tampa Bay Times via AP) TAMPA OUT; CITRUS COUNTY OUT; PORT CHARLOTTE OUT; BROOKSVILLE HERNANDO TODAY OUT; MANDATORY CREDIT

ST. PETERSBURG, Fla. – Hulk Hogan’s $140 million courtroom victory against Gawker for posting a sex tape of the former pro wrestler was many things, including a lurid inside look at the business of celebrity gossip and a dispute over what constitutes newsworthiness.

But legal experts generally agree on what it wasn’t: a serious threat to the First Amendment.

At this point, it is only a jury verdict, and an appeals court could reduce it or throw it out altogether. Even if it is upheld, its effects could be narrow, because in running the video, the sex-and-gossip site did something most media organizations wouldn’t even consider doing, legal experts said.

Or as University of Miami law professor Mary Anne Franks put it: “It’s hard to imagine that any credible media outlet is truly confused about the difference between a sex tape and the Pentagon Papers.”

Hogan sued Gawker for invasion of privacy after it published a video of him having sex with his best friend’s wife. Hogan said he didn’t know he was being taped. Gawker argued that the footage was newsworthy information about a public figure and thus protected by the First Amendment.