Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Chewy Molasses Cookies: Not flashy, just delicious

Not much to look at compared to its flashy holiday brethren, but a Chewy Molasses Cookie pliant and spice-scented and kind of perfect. (Sarah E. Crowder via AP)
Not much to look at compared to its flashy holiday brethren, but a Chewy Molasses Cookie pliant and spice-scented and kind of perfect. (Sarah E. Crowder via AP)
photo Not much to look at compared to its flashy holiday brethren, but a Chewy Molasses Cookie pliant and spice-scented and kind of perfect. (Sarah E. Crowder via AP)
photo Though not much to look at compared to its flashy holiday brethren, a Chewy Molasses Cookie is pliant, spice-scented and kind of perfect.

Holidays equal platters and tins of festive-looking cookies. Cookies with colored icing, cookies with sprinkles, cookies with fillings, cookies with layers.

An artistic cookie display is a thing of beauty, but let’s reach past it to grab a flat, modest, quiet molasses cookie. Not much to look at compared to its flashy holiday brethren, but pliant and spice-scented and kind of perfect.

Because the butter is melted in this recipe, you can just as easily mix them up with a spoon or a rubber spatula as an electric mixer. And also go for dark brown sugar, which contains more molasses.

Don’t overbake these cookies – unless you want crispy molasses cookies – then go right ahead and add another couple of minutes.

They will keep for three or four days in an airtight container. And they are good contenders for shipping; separate layers with wax or parchment paper, place additional crumbled paper in the bottom and top of the container to fill it, and make sure the container is well-padded before putting it in a box and sending it off to a lucky recipient.