An attorney for the Tennessee Valley Authority on Thursday described a judge’s coal ash cleanup order as “wholly disproportionate to the scant evidence of harm” as a case that has drawn wide interest from states and business groups went before a federal appeals court.
In his legal arguments before a panel of the 6th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Cincinnati, an attorney for environmental groups that won at the lower court level said a reversal would “disrupt” how the Clean Water Act has been administered for decades. Environmental activists claim TVA violated the Clean Water Act by storing coal ash in unlined storage ponds near a TVA power plant in Tennessee.
More than 20 states joined in submitting briefs to the appeals court, as did the U.S. Chamber of Commerce, national coal industry interests and more than a dozen other groups. Most of the states sided with TVA in urging the appeals court to overturn last year’s cleanup order.
The judge ordered coal ash to be excavated and removed at Gallatin, about 40 miles (65 kilometers) from Nashville. He cited Clean Water Act violations of pollutants leaking into the Cumberland River but said there was scant evidence of harm done by the pollution so far.
Coal ash is a byproduct of burning coal for power, and has heavy metals like arsenic, mercury and lead in it.
