NASHVILLE – Erlanger Health System’s bid to build a free-standing emergency department in Bradley County was denied Wednesday by the Tennessee Health Services and Development Agency.
The agency also denied a request from Tennova Healthcare – Cleveland, a 351-bed hospital in the heart of Bradley County, to do the same.
Representatives from each hospital presented arguments for why their project and not the other’s deserved a certificate of need, or CON, which grants health care providers permission to expand services based on an area’s medical needs. Both claimed that the emergency rooms at their main campuses are overwhelmed with patients who could be served by the new facilities.
After more than three hours of testimony, Dr. Kenneth Patric, the physician member of the agency’s board of directors, said he was “inclined to not approve either” project, because claiming a need for one facility and denying a need for the other didn’t make sense.
Board member Thom Mills, who voted for Tennova’s project and against Erlanger’s, said he was “struggling” with the idea that Erlanger’s presence in Bradley County could funnel patients away from local practices and into Hamilton County.
