KNOXVILLE, Tenn. (AP) – Both sides in the first-degree murder trial of former Division III college football player William Riley Gaul agree that he killed his 16-year-old ex-girlfriend by firing through her bedroom window.
What they disagree on, sharply, is his state of mind at the time.
This undated image provided by the Knox County Sheriff’s Office, shows William Riley Gaul, former Division III football player who is on trial this week in Tennessee on a first-degree murder charge. Both sides agree Gaul fired shots into the bedroom of 16-year-old ex-girlfriend Emma Walker, killing her as she slept. Prosecutors say he fired in anger over their breakup. Gaul’s defense says he never meant to killer her, but rather wanted to come “to her rescue and be her hero.” (Knox County Sheriff’s Office via AP, File)Knox County Assistant District Attorney Kevin Allen calls Gaul a “premeditated cold-hearted killer.” He said Gaul fatally shot Emma Walker in anger over the end of their tumultuous two-year relationship in November 2016.
Defense attorney Wesley Stone says Gaul, who was a freshman wide receiver at Tennessee’s Maryville College at the time, never meant to kill the high school cheerleader, and therefore isn’t guilty of first-degree murder. The team dismissed him after his arrest.
“Intentionally doing an act and intending to kill are two entirely different things,” Stone said Tuesday in his opening statement. “I think throughout this trial, that distinction will become apparent.”
