Despite pleas from a Chattanooga city councilman and former Hamilton County commissioner, a panel on Wednesday refused a developer’s plan for a new Publix store off South Broad Street.
In a five to four vote, the city’s Board of Zoning Appeals denied variances which would have allowed Alliance Realty Services to erect the Publix supermarket at South Broad and St. Elmo Avenue.
George Chase of Alliance Realty had no comment after the vote and it’s unclear what may happen next. The developer’s only appeal would be to Hamilton County Chancery Court.
For one member of the board, the proposed supermarket sitting in the rear of the 4-acre lot, rather than on South Broad, was a key shortcoming of the store plan under existing zoning.
Panel member Joe Manuel said that Uniform General Commercial zoning has “a clear philosophy – buildings built closer to the street.” He said the developer didn’t prove a hardship in order to receive the variances.
