Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Attorney for woman indicted in Signal Mountain slaying enters not-guilty plea

Rhonda Lorna Essenpreis
Rhonda Lorna Essenpreis
photo Contributed Photo/Hamilton County Sheriff’s Office / Rhonda Lorna Essenpreis

Rhonda Lorna Essenpreis, 64, pleaded not guilty Friday to first-degree murder in connection with the stabbing death of a man in her Signal Mountain home on Dec. 29.

Defense Attorney Mike Little entered the not-guilty plea on behalf of his client before Hamilton County Criminal Court Judge Don W. Poole as Essenpreis attended the hearing via livestream from Silverdale Detention Center.

Essenpreis is accused of killing Randal Paull Otto, 69, by stabbing him multiple times.

Little also represented Essenpreis during her preliminary hearing on Jan. 11, when she appeared before General Sessions Court Judge Christine M. Sell for a hearing to establish probable cause in the killing of Otto and to establish Essenpreis’ clarity of mind. Little will continue to represent Essenpreis.

During Friday’s hearing, Essenpreis appeared to look healthier and more aware of her surroundings than she did at the January hearing.