Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Tennessee court rules Confederate memorabilia in Giles County jury room not prejudicial

State flag of Tennessee / Getty Images
State flag of Tennessee / Getty Images


A Tennessee appellate court says there’s nothing “inherently prejudicial” in grand jurors and jurors deliberating the fates of Black people from inside the “Confederate jury room” in a courthouse in a town known as the birthplace of the Ku Klux Klan.

In a ruling made public Tuesday, a three-judge panel of the Tennessee Court of Criminal Appeals is refusing to vacate drug convictions meted out to a Black man, Barry Jamal Martin, by a jury that deliberated in a room awash in Confederate memorabilia. The room in question had walls adorned with a Confederate flag, portraits of Confederate President Jefferson Davis and Confederate Gen. John C. Brown, and other Confederacy memorabilia.

(READ MORE: Giles County agrees to drop use of private probation companies)

The ruling directly contradicts a prior decision by a separate panel of the Tennessee Court of Criminal Appeals issued in December 2021 that vacated the convictions of another Black man, Tim Gilbert, based on the jury’s exposure to the same memorabilia. The same attorney — Evan P. Baddour — represented both men in their appeals.