An Alabama death row inmate has sued to stop Alabama’s use of nitrogen gas executions, calling it cruel and unusual punishment.
In a lawsuit filed Thursday in the U.S. District Court for the Middle District of Alabama, David Wilson, sentenced to death for the 2004 murder of Dewey Walker during a robbery, argues that nitrogen gas asphyxiation is inherently inhumane and would be particularly painful for Wilson due to pre-existing health conditions, including chronic lung problems and sensory sensitivities.
The legal action follows questions about the execution of Kenneth Eugene Smith by nitrogen in January and criticisms of Alabama’s execution procedures more generally.
The lawsuit includes accounts from five reporters present during the execution, including Alabama Reflector reporter Ralph Chapoco, and one reporter who accompanied Smith’s family, who said that Smith experienced prolonged suffering on the gurney.
“This is an open and shut case. The media witnesses were there to be the public eye and to tell us what happened. They described minutes of writhing in agony and pain, and that is simply unconstitutional,” Bernard Harcourt, executive director of Columbia Law School’s Initiative for a Just Society and counsel for Wilson, said in a phone interview on Friday.
