Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Georgia men sentenced in landmark tax dodge case

A scheme led by two Atlanta-area men allowed investors to claim more than $1 billion in false federal tax deductions. Now, both men are heading to federal prison in a case that sounds a warning to others involved in what’s been called a shady tax dodge for the wealthy.

Chief U.S. District Judge Timothy Batten on Tuesday sentenced Jack Fisher, of Alpharetta, to 25 years, and James Sinnott, of Suwanee, to 23 years. The judge also ordered them to pay restitution of about half a billion dollars.

“It shocks the conscience, the degree of fraud in this case…,” Batten said in sentencing Fisher, adding later, “At the core of this is a level of greed that is sinister.”

Fisher, 71, and Sinnott, 52, were convicted in September in the nation’s first criminal trial involving a tax shelter known as syndicated conservation easements. The jury found them guilty of conspiracy to defraud the United States, wire fraud conspiracy, aiding and assisting the filing of false tax returns, and subscribing to false tax returns.

Also on Tuesday, two other Atlanta-area men charged in connection with the scheme pleaded guilty in separate hearings in Batten’s courtroom. CPAs Victor Smith and William Tomasello admitted to conspiracy to defraud the United States. They are scheduled to be sentenced in April.