Sitting in front of the Hamilton County Courthouse since 1919 is a statue of A.P. Stewart, a Confederate general during the Civil War, the deadliest conflict in this nation’s history fought over the preservation of slavery, fought over the right of a white man to claim a Black person as property.
Still to this day, that fight lives on. In 2025, we continue to wage war over who and who isn’t deemed worthy to share in this country’s wealth, not via firearms and military skirmishes, but over the collective understanding of our history — a war between lies and the truth.
A local example of this conflict is the public display of that bust of Stewart, a man who fought for the right to own another human being. In the wake of the nationwide George Floyd protests in 2020 — a part of the larger Black Lives Matter movement, one against systemic racism in American society — hundreds of citizens pushed the Hamilton County Commission to remove the statue.
“It hearkens back to slavery and the Civil War. It is rooted in the prolonged Jim Crow era of white supremacy, lynchings and segregation,” Betsy Darken, a former UTC professor, correctly pointed out in a petition to remove the statue in 2020. “It reflects the continuing presence of racism, conscious or unconscious, in our own times.”
Ultimately, the county commission voted against removal, as did a different set of commissioners in 2017. Arguments to keep Confederate statues like this in place vary, but the primary rationale from the political right, it is said, is the preservation of history.
