Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Jury convicts man accused of 2019 Bayberry Apartments double-homicide

Staff photo by Mason Edwards / Hamilton County court officers arrested Mark Caslin, 32, following his Aug. 7, 2026 conviction. He was found guilty of two charges of murder and one charge of attempted murder in connection with the 2019 Bayberry Apartments shooting.
Staff photo by Mason Edwards / Hamilton County court officers arrested Mark Caslin, 32, following his Aug. 7, 2026 conviction. He was found guilty of two charges of murder and one charge of attempted murder in connection with the 2019 Bayberry Apartments shooting.

A Hamilton County jury found a man guilty on two first-degree murder counts and one attempted first-degree murder count, among other charges after deliberating for several hours Friday.

Following the conviction, Criminal Court Judge Amanda Dunn sentenced Mark Caslin, 32, to life in prison in connection with the premeditated killing of Hollis Malone and Lyonel Gladden III and the near-killing of Jamel Sutton.

Dunn scheduled the sentencing for Caslin’s remaining convictions, which included especially aggravated robbery and a firearms charge, for Oct. 23.

Caslin was arrested in connection to the Dec. 8, 2019, shooting at the Bayberry Apartments in Chattanooga. Almost seven years elapsed between the incident and the conviction, as the pandemic and several attorney reassignments delayed the cases, according to prosecutor Paul Moyle.

After the verdict, Caslin’s defense attorney, David MacNeill, said his team fought as hard as possible to ensure the jury had all the information it needed.