Skip to main content
Thursday, November 12, 2026Nov 12

Investigators say moldy satchel helped them solve 1972 cold-case slaying

Cold Case Unit leader Mike Mathis, left, and District Attorney General Neal Pinkston talk next to a folder of evidence during a news conference on Wednesday, April 15, 2015, in the Hamilton County District Attorney's law library in Chattanooga.
Cold Case Unit leader Mike Mathis, left, and District Attorney General Neal Pinkston talk next to a folder of evidence during a news conference on Wednesday, April 15, 2015, in the Hamilton County District Attorney's law library in Chattanooga. Cold Case Unit leader Mike Mathis, left, and District Attorney General Neal Pinkston talk next to a folder of evidence during a news conference on Wednesday, April 15, 2015, in the Hamilton County District Attorney's law library in Chattanooga.
photo Harry Brooks Daniels

It started with a moldy satchel.

The faded leather pouch had been buried in Chattanooga Police Department files for decades. Inside were photos of an old fedora hat, of a crime scene off South Holly Street, and of the body of Leon Hicks.

Inside, too, were mugshots of the man investigators now say shot Hicks in 1972.

On Wednesday, District Attorney General Neal Pinkston announced his cold case unit had cleared the 43-year-old case. Much of the evidence needed to wrap it up was found in the satchel, which was only discovered when Pinkston requested boxes of two other cases’ files in March.

“[The satchel] just appeared in this box, and we don’t know what it was doing there,” Pinkston said.