Skip to main content
Thursday, November 12, 2026Nov 12

Cop pays thief’s tab for stolen birthday cake ingredients

Birthday Cake
Birthday Cake Birthday Cake
photo Birthday Cake

PORTSMOUTH, N.H. — A New Hampshire police officer dispatched to the scene of a shoplifting incident paid the thief’s tab after learning a woman stole the items to bake her child’s birthday cake.

The Portsmouth Herald reports Officer Michael Kotsonis, a 19-year member of the Portsmouth force, responded to a call last week at the Ocean State Job Lots after a woman had stolen cake mix, shortening and “a couple things of frosting.”

After investigating the theft and learning the woman’s identity, Kotsonis went to her home to recover the items. It was there that he found that the woman was a mother who wanted to bake her child a birthday cake.

Kotsonis says the mother’s actions weren’t right, but, “I’m not going to take away a kid’s birthday cake.” He went back to the store and bought the items.

A store employee reported his gesture to the newspaper. Frank Warchol, acting deputy police chief, said he wouldn’t have known about it, either, if not for a reporter’s call. He said Kotsonis exemplifies the department’s mission statement emphasizing community, commitment and compassion.