Skip to main content
Tuesday, November 10, 2026Nov 10

Louisiana teens’ deaths put spotlight on police chases

In this image provided by Janae Montgomery, Caroline Gill, left, and Maggie Dunn are shown in their cheerleading uniforms at Brusly High School in Brusly, Louisiana. Gill and Dunn were killed Saturday, Dec. 31, 2022, in a car crash. Authorities said a police officer from nearby Addis, La., crashed into the car the two girls were in after he joined a pursuit of a suspect that began in Baton Rouge. (Janae Montgomery via AP)
In this image provided by Janae Montgomery, Caroline Gill, left, and Maggie Dunn are shown in their cheerleading uniforms at Brusly High School in Brusly, Louisiana. Gill and Dunn were killed Saturday, Dec. 31, 2022, in a car crash. Authorities said a police officer from nearby Addis, La., crashed into the car the two girls were in after he joined a pursuit of a suspect that began in Baton Rouge. (Janae Montgomery via AP) In this image provided by Janae Montgomery, Caroline Gill, left, and Maggie Dunn are shown in their cheerleading uniforms at Brusly High School in Brusly, Louisiana. Gill and Dunn were killed Saturday, Dec. 31, 2022, in a car crash. Authorities said a police officer from nearby Addis, La., crashed into the car the two girls were in after he joined a pursuit of a suspect that began in Baton Rouge. (Janae Montgomery via AP)

NEW ORLEANS (AP) — It was a tragically high price to pay for catching a suspected car thief: two innocent teenagers dead and a police officer jailed, facing serious charges for a car crash that resulted from the pursuit.

Maggie Dunn, 17, and Caroline Gill, 16, who were cheerleaders for their high school in the southern Louisiana town of Brusly, died in the collision Saturday. They’re the latest fatalities among hundreds every year attributed to accidents involving police pursuits.

Many police departments have tightened their policies on such pursuits in recent years. However, National Highway Transportation Safety data show that 455 deaths were tied to police pursuits in 2020.

The Louisiana case is unusual in that the local prosecutor says the officer, 42-year-old David Cauthron, acted so recklessly that he should face charges and is preparing to ask a grand jury to consider bringing them.

Authorities say Cauthron, an officer in the town of Addis, joined a chase in rural West Baton Rouge Parish that started when police in Baton Rouge pursued a man suspected of stealing his father’s car.