GROSS REVENUESJuly 1 to September 30, 2009 – $173,700July 1 to September 30, 2010 – $114,811Percent difference – 34 percent decrease
If you talked to Red Bank Mayor Monty Millard three weeks ago, he would have called Tuesday a big day for “changing the city’s image” as it relates to snapshots of speeding cars.
On Nov. 16, two minutes into an inaugural speech filled with platitudes, Millard turned some heads: “Tonight I am asking [City Manager] Chris Dorsey to determine our options for the immediate removal of the red-light cameras and the speed van. He is to have this information available at our next agenda session on Dec. 7.”
But Tuesday was an empty-handed day for Dorsey, who faced Millard and other commissioners without any information about breaking a 12-year contract extension with American Traffic Solutions, the Arizona-based camera provider that collects about 60 percent of Red Bank’s ticket revenue.
“It’s not me stonewalling the mayor,” Dorsey said Tuesday.
Millard wasn’t mad.
“I’m not criticizing Chris,” he said. “He’s working on it.”
One thing both men know is the city is making less money on the cameras; records show a 34 percent gross revenue decrease from traffic-camera tickets issued between July and September of 2009 and 2010 — $173,700 to $114,811.
“So that’s a good thing,” Dorsey said during Tuesday’s agenda session, loudly clearing his throat toward reporters. “Wanted to make sure that got heard.”
After the session, Millard admitted meetings between City Attorney Arnold Stulce and American Traffic’s legal team, but he didn’t ballpark a potential severance fee. Either party can abandon the contract without financial penalty on each three year anniversary of its signing — 2013, 2016, 2019 or 2022.
But if Red Bank breaks the deal before 2013, officials close to the deal anticipate mediation and a potential breach of contract penalty. Considering the costs, Millard hedged a bit.
“I’m not going to spend an exorbitant amount of money to opt out,” the mayor said. “Even if we go to mediation, we’ll have legal fees and we don’t have a clue how much that’s going to run.”
Not many clues came during a mostly uneventful commission meeting Tuesday evening, but two residents discussed their opposing views on cameras, reciting familiar arguments for and against photo enforcement.
Stulce told the unsatisfied, anti-camera resident, “I don’t have to answer anything.” The young man then stomped away from Red Bank City Hall saying, “just like Washington.”
