Review: Robert Gipe's Appalachian trilogy concludes with 'Pop: An Illustrated Novel'

Contributed Photo by Amelia Kirby / Robert Gipe
Contributed Photo by Amelia Kirby / Robert Gipe

"POP: AN ILLUSTRATED NOVEL" by Robert Gipe (Ohio University Press, 346 pages, $29).

In 2015, Robert Gipe introduced Dawn Jewell in "Trampoline," an illustrated coming-of-age story about a Kentucky teenager who fights against strip mining in the 1990s. The setting is fictional Canard County, Kentucky - picture Faulkner's Yoknapatawpha thrust upward onto an Appalachian peak - and the characters include Dawn's extended mountain family. "Weedeater," a 2018 sequel, takes place in 2004, a time when Dawn is the young married mother of a precocious 4-year-old and fighting an opioid epidemic destroying her community and family. In Gipe's new "Pop," which the publisher describes as the final installment of the trilogy, Dawn's daughter Nicolette, now 17, becomes the novel's primary narrator.

It's 2016, and in advance of the looming presidential election, Dawn has begun to fray a bit at the edges. She spends most of her time online, eating junk food and drinking soda - regionally known as "pop," as in the book's title. After fighting endless battles against the pollution, drugs and poverty that plague Canard County, Dawn has become reluctant to engage with the world. Meanwhile, teenaged Nicolette spends much of her time away from home. Just as her mother did before her, she alternates between Dawn's Uncle Hubert, a backwoods entrepreneur, and Aunt June, an English teacher in town. With a school friend named Pinky, Nicolette decides to manufacture pop infused with local flavors, just ahead of a Hollywood film crew coming to town to film a movie about hillbillies and alien monsters. The story shifts seamlessly between scenes narrated by Dawn, Hubert and Nicolette, the narration occasionally passing through - rather than around - Gipe's Thurberesque drawings.

Although his work combines elements of the graphic novel with Southern fiction reminiscent of Harper Lee and Charles Portis, Gipe's background is in theater. In 2011, four years before his first novel, he was profiled in The New York Times for a series of plays based on the coal town of Harlan, Kentucky. The article praised Gipe's realistic dialog "drawn from real stories collected by Southeast Kentucky community students in a long-running oral history project."

In "Pop," as in Gipe's previous novels, the dialog reads something like a theatrical script, with the name of the speaker generally preceding quotes and characters sometimes speaking back and forth across several pages. In one such exchange, Dawn complains to June about the ridiculous science-fiction plot to be filmed in their hills.

I said, "Why their stories? Why can't they tell our stories? Why can't we tell our own stories?"

June said, "Maybe this is how we get to do that."

photo Ohio University Press / "Pop: An Illustrated Novel"

I said, "What happened to the 'Nothing about us without us' you used to teach us?"

She said, "I know but -"

The strong narrators and conversational tone pull the reader along, setting up powerful moments when the text abruptly switches to art. In one of these, Nicolette is staying with June. After a recording played in June's class - a tale recited by a "giant" dead poet whom Nicolette may or may not have met as a ghost - Nicolette writes a response, which her aunt reads. After asking why Nicolette seems sad, June says astutely, "Reading your paper makes me wonder if you're having trouble with something male."

The conversation moves into one of Gipe's drawings. Nicolette's wry face stares at the reader, framed on either side by the awkwardly scrawled capital letters of her reply. In these moments, the feeling becomes neither graphic novel nor theater, but documentary, as if the rough drawing is some filmed clip of oral history. The voices ring pure and true as those that James Agee chronicled in his nonfiction masterpiece "Let Us Now Praise Famous Men." "Pop's" unfolding events move toward elements that in a more traditional novel might verge into Southern gothic, yet Gipe's style keeps the action and characters utterly real - at times painfully so.

In a 2019 op-ed for The New York Times, Gipe wrote that in Appalachia "the 2016 election has strained the bonds we've forged - and has led to deep reflection and conversation within the region." He concluded his essay by asking of his home, "Who will release the energy hiding in our hearts?"

In "Pop," as throughout the entire Canard County trilogy, Gipe writes his powerful answer.

To read an uncut version of this review - and more local book coverage - visit, an online publication of Humanities Tennessee.

Upcoming Events