Skip to main content
Friday, November 13, 2026Nov 13

Opinion: In post-Roe America, questions arise over the meaning of fetal personhood

Photo by Jason Janik/The Dallas Morning News via The AP / Brandy Bottone poses at her home in Plano, Texas, on July 6, 2022. Brandy recently contested a HOV lane violation based on her pregnancy status.
Photo by Jason Janik/The Dallas Morning News via The AP / Brandy Bottone poses at her home in Plano, Texas, on July 6, 2022. Brandy recently contested a HOV lane violation based on her pregnancy status. Photo by Jason Janik/The Dallas Morning News via The AP / Brandy Bottone poses at her home in Plano, Texas, on July 6, 2022. Brandy recently contested a HOV lane violation based on her pregnancy status.

A Texas woman is fighting a ticket she received on June 29 for driving in a Dallas HOV lane. Under normal circumstances, this would not merit an editorial mention. But times have changed in Texas. The woman, Brandy Bottone, argues that, because she is pregnant, her fetus counts as a human with equal rights under Texas law. The Texas Legislature and Republican Gov. Greg Abbott made that bed with a big assist from the U.S. Supreme Court, now they must lie in it.

Get ready, America, because this is only the start of a tsunami of challenges to come as the nation grapples with the legal technicalities of anti-abortion laws before various state legislatures granting full personhood status to the unborn.

It’s quite possible that hundreds or thousands of laws will now have to be revised to account for the legal personhood status various red-state legislatures have granted to the unborn.

“This has my blood boiling,” Bottone, who is 34 weeks pregnant, told The Dallas Morning News. “How could this be fair? According to the new law, this is a life. I know this may fall on deaf ears, but as a woman, this was shocking.”

The officer issuing the ticket asserted that the rules governing two-person occupancy of cars in the HOV lane require that they be people “outside of the body,” Bottone said. But we checked the Texas Department of Transportation website stating the rules on HOV lane use, and nowhere does any such stipulation appear.