Two high-profile bank collapses over the past two weeks have rippled through the financial sector and left many savers seeking assurance that their own deposits are secure. For most individuals, balances at their bank or credit union are perfectly safe, subject to certain fairly high dollar limits beyond which they can easily eliminate additional risk.
It is useful and hopefully reassuring to recognize the distinct factors leading to those dramatic failures and just how little those institutions resembled the banks at which most of us maintain our checking and savings accounts. The collapse of Silicon Valley Bank in particular involved a confluence of disastrous management decisions, a substantial concentration of risky customers, and an apparent failure of regulatory oversight. It is also a good time to rehearse just how secure the US banking system remains for the average depositor.
Silicon Valley Bank or SVB was a California bank catering to a concentrated and uniquely risky clientele: venture capital-financed startups. The bank quintupled deposits during the post-covid boom and both served as a lender to these nascent ventures and held the substantial capital provided to them by their investors. Many customers deposited millions of dollars with SVB even though accounts were insured only to $250,000, with the rest at risk in the event the bank became insolvent. At most commercial banks, most deposits fall within FDIC limits. Nearly 90% of deposits at SVB were uninsured.
That mistake was down to depositors. What came next was a catastrophic management failure. Understanding that the deposits could be withdrawn at any time, SVB nevertheless attempted to goose profits by investing the deposits in long maturity Treasury bonds and mortgage securities, literally betting the ranch that interest rates would remain low forever.
As the Fed launched the most aggressive rate relative hiking cycle in history, the market value of the bank’s bond holdings tanked. Meanwhile, venture capital flows all but dried up, forcing start-ups to tap their deposit accounts. To meet liquidity demands, SVB had to dump $20 billion of bonds at fire sale prices while announcing its intention to raise additional capital. Sensing danger, depositors requested withdrawals just as the bank’s CEO begged investors and customers to “stay calm and not panic.” That is recondite banking argot for “get out of Dodge.”
