One of the pioneers of modern economics was not an economist but a psychologist. Daniel Kahneman passed away on March 27 at age 90, having altered the prevailing paradigms of human decision-making that had underpinned financial theory for two centuries.
Upon graduating from Hebrew University with a psychology degree, Kahneman found himself in the Israeli army assessing officer candidates. He discovered that the standard evaluation process was remarkably bad at predicting future success despite the institutional momentum behind it, leading him to question what he termed the “illusion of validity.” Although he didn’t know of Kahneman at the time, author Michael Lewis illustrated this illusion of validity in his 2003 best-selling book “Moneyball.”
The prevailing economic models from Adam Smith down to the early 1970s rested upon the assumption that human beings assimilate information and make accurate judgments based on that information. Homo economicus, or economic man, as 19th century theorist John Stuart Mill dubbed him, was a rational decision-maker driven by narrow self-interest seeking to optimize his own condition.
Of course, the presumption of perfect rationality did not always apply to every individual, as human imperfection and incomplete information was evident then as today. Yet the underlying thesis assumed that errors were random and effectively canceled each other out so that in the aggregate, humans behaved rationally. The intersection of the supply and demand curves for the market comprised the average of widely disparate individual tradeoffs but produced the “correct” market clearing price.
Kahneman and his friend and collaborator Amos Tversky applied their previous psychological research on decision-making to reach a distinctly different conclusion. They demonstrated through a series of clever experiments in the 1970s that human beings do not behave as impersonal calculating machines even in the aggregate and that human error is systematic.