Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Whitfield County grand jury indicts former Varnell, Ga., officer James Smith on homicide by vehicle

photo Varnell Police Officer James Smith was driving this cruiser when he crashed into Leon Thurman’s car March 5. Thurman was at least the sixth Georgian killed in recent years in a crash involving a law enforcement vehicle. Contributed Photo by Michael Thurman

A Varnell, Ga., police officer who was speeding when his cruiser slammed into the side of a 70-year-old newspaper carrier’s car has been charged in the man’s death.

A Whitfield County grand jury on Thursday indicted former Officer James Smith on charges of homicide by vehicle in the first degree and reckless driving in connection with the death of Leon Thurman.

Thurman was a retired Cohutta, Ga., farmer and longtime newspaper carrier for the Dalton Daily Citizen.

Conasauga District Attorney Bert Poston declined to give the exact speed that the six-year veteran was traveling seven months ago, but he said it was “substantially above the posted speed limit.”

The morning of the March 5 crash, Smith had a 19-year-old passenger, who was part of a citizen ride-along program, in his cruiser when he smashed broadside into Thurman’s Dodge Neon as the man was crossing four lanes on Cleveland Highway. Smith was not responding to an emergency, and his blue lights were not on.