NASHVILLE – A top Chattanooga-based BlueCross BlueShield of Tennessee official is questioning a private data firm’s assertions the nonprofit insurer paid out $11 million in medical overcharges during a three-year period in its role as a third-party administrator of state employees’ health plan.
In his Sept. 3 letter to Tennessee Finance Commissioner Butch Eley and Benefits Administration Executive Director Laurie Lee, BlueCross Executive Vice President and Chief Operating Officer Scott Pierce said the company conducted its own “high-level” analysis of claims in the date range that Connecticut-based ClaimInformatics, which conducted the initial review, said it used.
It “revealed that substantially all of the alleged excessive payments in excess of billed charges were based upon a lack of understanding of our payment policies,” Pierce wrote.
Because BlueCross pays certain provider types at a contracted flat rate per visit, Pierce said, the flat rate “applies regardless of whether the billed charges are above or below the rate. This program has resulted in significant overall savings” to the state health plan.
ClaimInformatics said in a preliminary June report that the state health insurance plan’s third-party administrators, BlueCross BlueShield and Cigna, overpaid at least $17.58 million over a three-year period in bill claims by professional providers such as physicians. Those overpayments are “ready for repayment,” the firm asserted.
