Opinion: Nashville’s Jim Crow 2.0

Photo/George Walker IV / The Associated Press / State Rep. Justin Jones, D-Nashville, delivers remarks outside the state Capitol on Monday, April 10, 2023, in Nashville, Tenn. Jones, who was expelled last week from the GOP-led Tennessee House over his role in a gun-control protest on the House floor, was reinstated Monday after Nashvilles governing council voted to send him straight back to the Legislature.
Photo/George Walker IV / The Associated Press / State Rep. Justin Jones, D-Nashville, delivers remarks outside the state Capitol on Monday, April 10, 2023, in Nashville, Tenn. Jones, who was expelled last week from the GOP-led Tennessee House over his role in a gun-control protest on the House floor, was reinstated Monday after Nashvilles governing council voted to send him straight back to the Legislature.

Tennessee loves to be recognized for its amazing vistas, historic arts and culture and music icons. But the news these days is full of what transpired in the state capital over the last week: the expulsion of two Black state representatives punished for protesting on the House floor for safer gun laws following a mass shooting at the private Christian Covenant School in Nashville.

The mostly white, male GOP supermajority in the state House denied any elements of racism in the decision to boot the Black legislators but not the white female lawmaker. Social media users exploded over the actions; the Twitter crowd declared Nashville Jim Crow 2.0, referring to the laws mandating segregation post-Civil War.

Newspapers reminded readers that the 1859 state capitol was built by enslaved people. And there's a new spotlight on how the Ku Klux Klan originated in Tennessee and became a paramilitary focused on reversing progressive Reconstruction-era policies elevating the rights of Blacks in the South. Justin Jones, one of the two lawmakers who were expelled (both have since been reinstated), had previously campaigned to remove a bust of an early KKK grand wizard from the capital.

Some House members understood what was at stake. Memphis Rep. Karen Camper, a Democrat, urged: "For a simple rule violation we have elevated this to the highest level of admonishment. That's not democracy ... I beg of you not to do that today."

Memphis is where the Rev. Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. was assassinated and where Justin Pearson, the other young Black man expelled, was a representative. The state legislature had already gerrymandered the area to minimize the influence of Black constituents and was irate at Pearson's efforts to be heard, seen and acknowledged. Pearson said he had heard that state lawmakers and other Nashville officials had threatened to cut funding to Shelby County if he was reappointed to the seat.

Compare today's situation to 20 years ago when Republicans in the Tennessee legislature, including then-state Sen. Marsha Blackburn, coordinated with protesters to intimidate and disrupt passing a state income tax. They weren't censured or expelled. But Republican House Speaker Cameron Sexton had described the March protest in the House chamber as an "insurrection," comparable to Jan. 6 at the U.S. Capitol.

The pushback has been fast. The Nashville Metro Council voted unanimously to reappoint Rep. Justin Jones to House District 52 seat as an interim representative.

As national media — even "Saturday Night Live" — put a glaring spotlight on Tennessee and its GOP General Assembly, Republican Gov. Bill Lee signed an executive order to tighten background checks and urged lawmakers to pass — in this legislative session — an "order of protection" law, akin to a red flag law, that allows for removing guns from people dangerous to themselves or others.

Amazing what national pressure can do!

Will what has transpired in Nashville evolve into a nationwide movement, an evolution that could include ending the gerrymandering that diminishes the representation of people of color and the poor? Could this mean that gun safety advocates won't be silenced anymore?

Maybe I'm dreaming, but I live in hope that our wild 2024 election might actually produce democratic results — and take us further away from Jim Crow 2.0.

Contact Deborah Levine, an author, trainer/coach and editor of the American Diversity Report, at deborah@diversityreport.com.

Upcoming Events