Skip to main content
Monday, November 16, 2026Nov 16

Opinion: Frederick Douglass and the hecklers’ veto

File photo/Ozier Muhammad/The New York Times / A stature of abolitionist Frederick Douglass that is exhibited on Capitol Hill in Washington is shown on Sept. 13, 2012.
File photo/Ozier Muhammad/The New York Times / A stature of abolitionist Frederick Douglass that is exhibited on Capitol Hill in Washington is shown on Sept. 13, 2012.

Heckling mobs, determined to shout down speech they disagree with, are not unique to our time. Frederick Douglass’s encounter with one in 1845 can teach us much about them.

At that time, America was polarized. Slavery was the issue, and opinions were boiling over. Douglass, the former slave turned powerful abolitionist orator, had been free for seven years. He had just published his memoir, “Narrative of the Life of Fredrick Douglass, An American Slave,” and had become an international abolitionist celebrity.

In September of that year, he boarded a ship for Ireland to promote his book and to escape the risk that his former master might drag him back into the evil institution.

The ship that carried Douglass east, like the country disappearing over the horizon behind him, was consumed with the slavery debate. “From the moment we first lost sight of the American shore,” Douglass wrote, “till we landed at Liverpool, our gallant steam-ship was the theatre of an almost constant discussion of the subject of slavery.” It started off “cool” but grew “hotter every moment as it advanced.”

The debate possessed the ship. “If suppressed in the saloon, it broke out in the steerage; and if it ceased in the steerage, it was renewed in the saloon; and if suppressed in both, it broke out with redoubled energy, high upon the saloon deck, in the open, refreshing, free ocean air.”